My biggest complaint is their check in policy. I have never heard of such restricted hours and then the requirement to pay, even if you give advanced notice. Even though we reached around 10pm, Andre charged us the higher rate AFTER his 'check-in' stating the check in time begins after his check-in. That's plain cheating.
Here are other CONS/issues:
Low curved ceilings by the bed; water temperature was warm, not great; the sliding shower door is difficult to slide causing loud screeching sounds; appreciate the act of the bassinet however it was broken; and multiple steps (as they had disclosed) to get to the room. Parking is an absolute nightmare here because we are told to call 30 mins in advance to obtain the car which is more than half a mile or about 850 meters. Plus, you have to drive down the main street of the shopping amongst all the tourists. If you are leaving or trying to get in around the school hours, you will get stuck for about 30 minutes behind a traffic light. The in-room bar refrigerator isn't working well.
PROS: the place is clean and cleaned daily with new towels. it's close to everything in Amalfi like the shopping, restaurants, farmer's market, ferry services, etc. I liked the hand sanitizer they supplied.
So, overall, if you plan to use a car or check in after their restrictive hours, I would read above and highly consider other options.