Pretty clean hotel, there were a couple small things that werent totally spotless but I'd give it an honest 7.5/10 for that. The roof and location was really the selling point for me, and it did NOT disappoint! Incredible views and literally walking distance from everything you could possibly need. Times square is about a10 minute walk, and the best pizza, 2 bros in next door. Liberty bagel is right around the corner too, and dim sum sam for the crispiest pork belly of time. Would definitely stay here again, but would try to book it much further in advance because the price tag for this hotel is rather high. The only real inconvenient thing I ever ran into was the tv remote situation in my room (there were 2 different ones, I called front desk and they sent someone and fixed it for me!) and from time to time the elevator lines got crowded and would make frequent stops. Also just be aware u might be jammed in an elevator with like 15 people maybe once or twice if you stay for just a weekend. There really wasnt anywhere to really put your trash, so we collected