It may seem hokey to have all six criteria rated a 5, but this cottage exceeded all expectations. It was comfortable with privacy and plenty of space and a nice view. The porch on one side was completely private, mostly due to a hedge that blocked the distant road. When we mentioned to the owners one morning that the kitchen was missing a few things (like a peeler, a measuring cup, etc.), they brought the items over before lunch! And it is only about 1 km to town and what certainly must be among PEI's best oysters.