I really enjoyed my stay at the Starlight. I didn't shop around much, so I can't speak to the value compared to competitors in Tirana. But I felt like I got my money's worth without a doubt.
My room was large, clean, and modern. I had a great view of the city and a balcony which was nice. The A/C worked really well which was a lifesaver because it was extremely hot outside. I didn't interact with the staff a ton, but when I did they were friendly and professional.
The neighborhood felt safe to me and it was very walkable to get to the main square and surrounding attractions. There are several corner stores with cheap water, snacks, etc. on the same block.
Maybe if I had one tiny area for improvement it would be that the shower was hard to get the temperature right.