I booked this property for my family to stay in during my wedding week. It's a lovely location, convenient to the beach and everything else with Bald Head. The property is well appointed (bikes and beach chairs!), the beds/furniture were comfortable, and Ainsley was incredibly friendly, responsive, and accommodating.
A few items kept it from being a top notch experience...
First, and the most minor - a few of the bikes had flat tires and needed to be serviced.
Second is cleanliness. The property was mostly clean, but there were clearly some overlooked areas (like a bug smushed on an outlet cover by the stove, dusty air intakes - like waving in the breeze dust, and visible dust on decorations). To be fair, I did ask for an earlier check-in if possible because of arrival times, but some of this dust couldn't have been from the previous guest, it's been there awhile building up, and its not like I was looking behind pictures, its right in your face.
The 3rd is the mildew smell in the crofter. I know its humid, I know its an island. But its overwhelming and probably in the walls or under the garage.
All that to say, I would stay here again - just maybe not in the crofter haha.